Review & Discuss Gopen & Swan ideas: * Subject-Verb separation & meaning - readers expect grammatical verb to follow the subject almost immediately; extra words before the verb tend to be igonred! - make the verb meaningful * Single Function - Each unit of discourse, no matter what the size, is expected to serve a single function, to make a single point. * A sentence structure that meets readers' expectations; [Topic position] [details] [stress position]. (1) The beginning of the sentence (the "topic position") serves two reader expectations: (a) what the story of the sentence is about (b) links back to familiar information and/or frames sentence (c) "what's it about": perspective and context (2) The end of the sentence ("stress position") (a) what the reader will remember / take away (b) leans forward into the next sentence or other bit of writing. (c) "what's the point": primary emphasis Topic and stress are *especially* for skimmers (but all readers expect them!); middle has the details for the truly interested reader. * Don't make reader construct linkages between units of writing by themselves. ------ On paragraphs: (1) It is much more complicated to think of the various expectations that readers have about paragraphs. We will continue discussion of paragraphs on Thursday. (2) Some good heuristics: A common (but not the only) form of paragraph defines an "issue" and makes a "point" about it. (a) Treat a paragraph like a sentence: -- the beginning is the "topic position" (the "issue" is here) -- the end is the "stress position" (the "point" can be anywhere but is often here) -- the middle contains the details (b) To give a paragraph "flow": -- the topic position of each sentence should reach back to old info and frame the sentence. -- the stress position should have new information -- each sentence should lean into the next (c) Each writing unit should serve a single function. -- as a simple check: the last sentence should match the first. (I usually ask if I can "get the point" by looking only at the beginning and end of the paragraph) -- More broadly, each sentence in the paragraph should support the main point of that paragraph. Other kinds of paragraphs, e.g.: -- tell a story (can be very satisfying if well-signaled) -- collect together a list of facts, definitions, instructions, etc. (sometimes necessary, but usually not too satisfying)